The IHL Principle of Distinction in the Context of Asymmetric and Hybrid Armed Conflicts

Jus in Bello – The IHL Principle of Distinction in the Context of Asymmetric and Hybrid Armed Conflicts

Abstract — Armed conflicts are increasingly assuming an asymmetric character through the involvement of non-State actors such as terrorist groups, militants, and insurgents. This phenomenon presents  complex  challenges  for  the  international  legal framework regulating warfare (Jus ad Bellum and Jus in Bello). This paper sets out to critically evaluate the legal challenges and practical difficulties which attain the application of the IHL principle   of   distinction   in   asymmetric   and   hybrid   armed conflicts. While acknowledging the progress made in articulating the norms of ‘jus in bello’, the paper highlights persistent and pervasive problems in the application of the law governing armed conflicts to battlefield situations. The paper’s key objective is to counsel the necessity for the further refinement and granulation of current ‘signature policies’ involving the use of armed drones in the targeting of terror suspects. This is done with a view to attaining a greater degree of accuracy, clarity and precision in calibrating the vital distinction between civilian status and the various categories of presumed combatants. The conclusion posits the impossibility of attaining the rule of distinction in the use of weapons  of  mass  destruction  (WMDs).  It  further  argues  that when viewed from this perspective the mere possession and stockpiling of WMDS could per se be construed as constituting the requisite mens rea or animus belligerendi of preparation for the possible future commission of a war crime.

Keywords – International law, law of armed conflicts, asymmetric warfare, IHL principle of distinction, war crimes

Dr. George K. Ndi
Law Research Group & PGR Leader
The Law School
University of Huddersfield
Queensgate, Huddersfield, West Yorkshire, England
UNITED KINGDOM

Written by

The author didnt add any Information to his profile yet